A. Victoria Mixon, Editor Services Home About Contact Magazine
Subscribe [RSS]
Follow Me [twitter]
Copyright
  • Trapped.

    Isem’s eyes flickered around the room as he shifted on the chair. There wasn’t much to see. A small table lined with chairs, a fire licking away at the logs in the fireplace. A wood stove, a sink, and a counter where his captor stood, back to him. She was a short woman, but powerful. Overpowering her was not an option. To Isem’s right, an open door beckoned him with the inviting rays of dawn. His hands twitched as they rested on the table. If I could just make it to the door, he thought, she’d never catch me.

    He glanced back at the woman. But if she catches me… He shuddered at the thought. The punishment facing him was bad enough without anything else tacked on. The prospect of freedom was too tempting though, and Isem braced himself against the table in preparation for a mad dash for the exit. On three…
    —Richard Young

    Developmental Edit

    Terrific tension! Syd Field, the quintessential playwright, always begins a scene as close to the end as possible. You don’t get much closer than this!

    Tense? check
    Detailed? check
    Raises a question? check Will he try to escape?
    Drop-kicks us off the end? check Will he make it?

    What does this paragraph tell us about the book we’re starting? A male character named Irem is being held against his will by a woman physically stronger than him and apparently planning to punish him. They appear to be in a home, and it is dawn.

    Do I want to follow this character through a whole novel? I’m ready to at least follow him to the next page! I want to see if he makes it. And whether he does or not, I want to know why he’s being held against his will and by whom.

    Genre? I couldn’t find Isem in any name catalogues online, so I’m guessing it’s fantasy. It could be adult, children’s, or YA (I suspect the reason Isem can’t overpower the short woman is because he’s smaller than she is—a child), but there could also be a thriller or mystery element.

    Do we need to know who the character is, how they got here, where they were before? I like not knowing. That’s tension!

    Do we need to know what’s going to happen next? I am POISED to find out!

    Does this paragraph drop us right smack in a specific moment in this character’s story? Yes, it does. The sun is coming up, and Isem desperately wants to make a break for it.

    So let’s talk about the structure of it. This is a very tense moment. There’s a certain amount of explanation that can be left to the reader’s imagination, inferred from the characters’ action and internal dialog. There is also one instance of sunlight “beckoning,” which is a problem because beckoning is a very specific gesture performed with the fingers, meaning inanimate objects—even fingerless objects—cannot beckon. Can this be made any shorter and snappier, while removing the explanations and beckoning and retaining the tension and ambiance?

    Copy & Line Edit

    Trapped.

    Isem’s eyes flickered around the room—a small table, chairs, a fire licking at the logs in the fireplace. A short, powerful woman stood at the sink with her back to him. The light of dawn came through an open door, and his hands twitched on the table. If I made it to the door, she’d never catch me.

    He glanced at the woman. But if she catches me. . . He shuddered. Isem braced himself against the table. On three. . .

    No Comments

No Responses to “Free HOOK Edit: Trapped—”

  1. I immediately liked the idea of a woman holding a man hostage! :O

    I really liked the editing on this one as well. Good example of writer and editor working together to make “beautiful music.”

    Most bodacious!

  2. I love how this starts with the one-word paragraph. It creates great tension!

    Victoria-

    I’m not sure I understand why you don’t like the use of the word “beckoned.” I totally get that it’s a human gesture, but if the open door beckoned to him, isn’t that just personification? Showing us that the door being open was calling him to escape into those inviting rays of sunlight? I really like the use of the word there, so I’m just a little confused. If you have a chance, I’d love some more explanation on this particular edit. Thanks!

    Also, I wanted to say how wonderful it’s been to read these hooks, along with your analysis and edits. It’s been quite educational and entertaining! Thanks for all the time you’ve put into them.

  3. Hi, Gretchen! Thanks for the kind words!

    “Beckoned” is one of the more commonly-misused words in English these days, which makes it a cliche. When you state that inanimate objects act and feel as if they were human, you are either writing magical realism or you are saying things that can’t possibly be true.

    Fiction is about telling the truth. Flannery O’Connor addresses this issue extensively and with great insight and charm in Mystery and Manners.

    The topic of cliches is a whole blog post unto itself. Thanks for the idea! I’ll put it on the list.

    Victoria

  4. Ah, that does make sense. Thanks for the response! I’ll have to check out Mystery and Manners.

    And yes, please write a post about avoiding cliches! I could probably use some help there. :)

  5. Another great example of staring int he middle of the story for maximum tension. (Looks like we’ve got the in media res thing down!) Definitely pulls you in and drop kicks you out!

  6. Yes – the “Trapped” does it for me. An immediate “Oh dear, that can’t be good” reaction. Everything that comes after paints how “trapped” the character is, and I’m right there wanting to find out.

    Nicely done – and the edits tighten everything so it hums.

  7. I liked the way you started off your storyline, Richard! Very intriguing! I do have lots of questions, so would certainly keep turning the pages!

Leave a Reply



Upcoming Release: March 2010
All aspects of writing fiction explored copiously, luxuriously, minutely, indiscriminately, and with a certain amount of personal prejudice.

Clients’ Books


Bhaichand Patel is the author of two nonfiction books: Chasing the Good Life (Penguin Books India, October, 2006), and Happy Hours (Penguin Books India, October, 2009). I recently edited Patel's debut novel, When the Streets Were Dark and Cold.


Although my contribution to Baby Jesus Pawn Shop was only a peer critique and participation in a standing ovation, in 2009 I edited two nonfiction essays for my friend Lucia Orth.


The poet Chris Ryan is the author of The Bible of Animal Feet (Farfalla Press, 2007). He has new stories forthcoming in Pank, Anemone Sidecar, and A Cappella Zoo. I edited Ryan's debut novel The Ishmael Blade.